- "Reapers keep attacking the police station down the street! Help them!"
- — Pedestrian
Cole is contacted by a woman in an alley about a massive battle between the Reapers and the police. As Cole runs toward the battle, he has a choice; he can either step in and take down the Reapers, or wait to see who will defeat the other and then kill whoever is left. Once Cole makes his choice, he defeats the Reapers and frees that section of the Neon from any further Reaper involvement.
Upon completion, Cole receives 100 XP and slightly reduces enemy activity in the Neon District of Empire City.
- Another option instead of waiting during the Evil Karma choice is you can attack the police and still gain the karma choice award, but the Reapers will still attack you instead of assisting you.